High School Athlete of the Year Winners
- Andrew Taglianetti, 2007
- Dom DeCicco, 2006
- John Pelusi, 2004
- Fred Bacco, 2003
- Adam DiMichelle, 2002
- Bob Tudi, 2001
- Bruce Gradkowski, 2000
- Dino DiNardo, 2000
- Mike Vernillo, 1999
- Mike Vernillo, 1998
- Gina Nacarrato, 1995
- Dante Calabria, 1991
- Paul Failla, 1990
- Pia Pitchok, 1989
- Pamela Pitchok, 1989
- Cathy Torchia, 1988
- John Dasta, 1988
- Beth Natale, 1987
- Al Lardo, 1987
- Tony Aliucci, 1986
Previous Chapter Honor Winners:
- Man of the Year
- Domenic T. Roppa Memorial Award
- Coach of the Year
- High School Athlete of the Year
- College Athlete of the Year
- Lifetime Achievement
- Chapter Scholarships Awards
- Legal Professional
- Education Professional
- Arts & Entertainment
- Joe Natoli Community Achievement
- Business Professional
- Medical Professional
- Founders Award
- Special Recognition Award
- Sportsman of the Year
- Sportswoman of the Year
- College Athlete of the Year
- Woman of the Year
- Pro Athlete of the Year
- Athlete of the Year
- Pittsburgh Legends
